Is it too much to ask for someone to make a believable movie about adolescent reptilian martial arts masters mentored by a talking rat?
Perhaps I just answered my own question.
I definitely was hoping to see such a movie when I walked (or practically skipped) to the midnight premiere of Michael Bay’s adaptation of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles series — one of my favorite improbable childhood stories.
I knew coming in that the pre-production of this film was fraught with a lot of controversy. Bay has always been a racy guy, for many reasons. For example, when asked about all the complaints and insults being aimed at his films (particularly Transformers 4), Michael Bay just shrugged. "They love to hate," he said. "And I don't care; let them hate. They're still going to go see the movie." And true to form, Transformers 4 made over $100 million in one weekend despite the scathing public reviews.
As for the beginnings of his Turtle trouble, that all started in 2012 when Bay announced that he was going to change the mutants from turtles into aliens. I (and perhaps about 80% of the TMNT fans on the face of the planet) was outraged. The internet fairly exploded with angry blogs, videos, and emails demanding Bay’s head on a platter for suggesting such a thing. And the incredible thing is… he backed down. He apologized to the fans, went back to the drawing board, and even included a little joke for us in all the trailers.
I knew coming in that the pre-production of this film was fraught with a lot of controversy. Bay has always been a racy guy, for many reasons. For example, when asked about all the complaints and insults being aimed at his films (particularly Transformers 4), Michael Bay just shrugged. "They love to hate," he said. "And I don't care; let them hate. They're still going to go see the movie." And true to form, Transformers 4 made over $100 million in one weekend despite the scathing public reviews.
“Are they aliens?” asks a skeptic of the main character.
“No; that’s stupid. They’re turtles.”
Seeing the producer relax and actually honor the fans of this franchise gave me a bit more hope than I’d originally anticipated when the previews started coming out. While I was aware that Bay also tends to like over-flashy robots and awkward sexual innuendos and inexplicable use of slow-motion, I do admit that after watching the trailers for this film, I allowed myself a smidgen of hope that he might actually be the perfect person to head a ninja-turtle movie. After all, he doesn’t even have to really focus on the plot here: all he needs to do is give us the blockbuster action and great teen humor that he’s known for. Did he deliver?
Well… allow me to put it this way (and insert the necessary cheesy joke): I kind of wish movies were like pizza, in that if you're not satisfied with the delivery you can get a little money back.
Ironically, in the end, it was the movie that ended up judging Bay, and not me… nor the dozens of other fans decked out in ninja masks that had streamed into the theatre with me (though some of them tried to express their own opinions during the screening, as you’ll soon find out). So allow me to explain.
Ironically, in the end, it was the movie that ended up judging Bay, and not me… nor the dozens of other fans decked out in ninja masks that had streamed into the theatre with me (though some of them tried to express their own opinions during the screening, as you’ll soon find out). So allow me to explain.
We open in New York City, following the less-than-she-hoped-for news career of April O’Neil, played by Megan Fox of the Transformers saga. She’s trying to become a serious reporter and investigate a recent city crime wave, but all her bosses think she’s fit for is the role of sexy airhead who does what she’s told (gee, sounds like Fox’s career with Bay in a nutshell — or rather, half-shell). But O’Neil slaves in her free time to bring the city justice anyway, and after perhaps ten minutes of nothing but interacting with boring, stereotypical human beings, she finally winds up meeting the four wise-cracking vigilantes we were all waiting for!
It’s a lot for her to take in, obviously. She must be admiring their new costume-designs as much as the rest of us. After they feebly attempt to explain to her what they are, she can only dumbly repeat back, “Ninja… mutant… turtle… teenagers?”
“Well when you put it like that, it sounds ridiculous,” snorts the turtle in the purple mask.
Yes it does, Donatello. Yes it does.
If you take something that you’ve simply accepted for so long and then rearrange it just to try and make it fresh, you may make it so new that you have to wind up forcing yourself to re-believe it all over again. And after only just introducing us to the wacky characters that we grew up loving, Bay then attempts to do exactly that… rearrange the turtles’ origin story almost beyond recognition.
All that was accident or chance in the original series (like the turtles’ mutation, April’s encounters with them, their love of pizza, how they came to learn ninjutsu) has been rewritten. So much so that after a few minutes of cringing in our seats, one of us finally stood up after learning how the animals ended up in the sewers and shouted (in a more R-rated way), “THAT’S BALONEY!”
We all giggled. Then cheered. And as the rest of the origin story kept unfolding, we all just kept laughing at it. Because Bay was trying so hard to convince us that what he had was really a plausible story… and half the fun of the Ninja Turtles franchise is the fact that we as fans know it could never happen, and don’t care because we just want to get on with it and enjoy the fun characters we can relate to. But Bay only gives us a few really fun scenes with our scaly friends, and even then he still mostly glosses over them for the sake of trying to ‘fix’ the saga… all the while somehow ignoring what was actually broken in the original stories — like buildings collapsing for no reason, ninja-weapons somehow winning in a contest against armored cars, adrenaline shots acting as a permanent cure-all for people on the verge of death, or the bad guys being evil because, well, because they’re bad guys. The head villain, a billionaire named Erik Sacks (who plans to attack and then save the city in order to become rich...er) even has goons with creepy masks and tends to toss out cheesy one-liners like, “Soon the city will be ours,” and “Time to take a bite out of the big apple,” to boot!
In fact, by the end I was almost laughing again, at how much Bay ended up resembling the head villain in his own movie. He professed to be a savior, and despite how obviously-evil he was going to be, he still somehow got away with a perfectly-far fetched scheme that ended up with him finally getting his hands on all the green that he wanted.
Yes, I’m just as guilty as the next viewer. I knew Bay’s reputation, I knew the risks, and yet I spent twenty dollars on the midnight premiere anyway. Because dash it all, I wanted to see four mutant turtles tearing up baddies and the dance floor! And every now and then, I got to see just that — and it was glorious!
But I had to force myself to swallow it. After all the butchering of the plot that Bay did, I’m starting to wonder if we might have been better off letting him make the characters into aliens. At least then we would have ended up semi-believing a new story, instead of semi-disbelieving the original.
Perhaps there’s only a lose-lose situation to come of this: either Bay directs a sequel, or else nobody makes a sequel because the film is considered a flop. I’m honestly not sure which would be worse.








